Saturday, January 20

Bookish Musings: ARC for Sale?


I can't seem to get enough of these discussion posts now. Haha. I admit I have a lot of stuff to say when it comes to current events in the our country and the world in general. I work with US clients so I might have used the "Trump" card (excuse for the pun) as small talk. In the book world there is always going to be much to talk about - hyped (or not so hyped) books, author gossip, cover reveals, reviews, piracy (an entirely different can of worms), etc.

One of the recurring issues that seem to pop up every now and then are ARCs - how to get them, who usually gets them, and can they be sold or bought. I did a little rant about getting ARCs on a previous post you can find here. On this post I'll discuss the issue of buying and selling ARCs.
What is an ARC? 

If you are a long time reader or book blogger, you probably know what an ARC is. For those who are new to the scene it's the acronym for Advanced Readers Copy or Advance Reading Copy. Readers/Bloggers usually get this directly from an author or their publisher upon request, while merchants (bookstores/outlets/online stores/etc) sometimes get sent these. ARCs are sent out before the books are published and might not have the final editing or actual cover of the books that will go out for selling. Reviewers (bloggers/media) use the ARCs for pre-marketing purposes of the book and will help publishers gauge the response of the public in anticipation of the actual release date.

Please note that ARCs do cost money to produce and are shipped to select few at the authors or publishers cost.

So here is what's going on

Recently some people have been selling ARCs on eBay again. I say again, because like I said at the beginning that it's on on going issue. Authors and readers alike have been taking their frustrations in Twitter:



Seeing these tweets, I totally understand where the authors are coming from. Despite us international bloggers not really getting any ARCs (unless from really sweet Authors), selling ARCs paints a bad picture about the people who do get them. From the standpoint of a reader/blogger like me, I 100% agree with them. It is sleazy and underhanded for people to sell books they got for free. I treasure all the ARCs (and e-ARCs) I've gotten and they will eventually be proudly displayed in my shelf (once I get it..Hehe). 


Not for Sale

It's big enough to read and easy enough to follow. Legally there is no law that will prohibit a sale of a book that we already own, ARC or not. To my fellow readers and bloggers, we just need to practice a little bit of discretion when it comes to the ARC that we get. If the book has not been released yet then our job is to read the book, write a review, and help the author "market" their work.

But what if the books have already passed the publicity and hype stage? Like if they've been on the shelves for at least a few years? I'm a book hoarder so I would still keep the ARCs and consider them part of my collection. Eventually these books are going to become collectibles or memorabilia.  It wouldn't matter if I bought a finished copy, the ARC would still stay. If you didn't want to keep an ARC a few years old then maybe that is the time they can be sold, to collectors or readers looking for books that are already out of print. I used to sell 2nd hand books, but time has changed my view and I would just pass them on to those who want to read them or want them to be part of their collection. I would buy an ARC for my collection, but in respect to authors I wouldn't buy one before the final copies are actually released.


I am one of these less fortunate (marginalized/international) bloggers and I am open to get those ARCs if you don't want them.

**********

What do you think of about the reselling of ARCs? Do you think the authors are just making a big deal out of it? What would you do to an ARC you didn't like or did not request? I'd like to here your thoughts on the matter.


16 comments:

  1. I'm for the 100% do not ever sell ARCs party.
    I think those who have them and want to part with them need to be better with their trading and stop just asking for unicorns

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. A trade would be a good idea or maybe a donation. But selling? It's very distasteful to make money out of something that was given to you.

      Delete
  2. Definitely agree! ARCs are so precious, I cannot understand why people would sell it! It's an honour to receive an ARC, regardless of whether physical of eARC version! If I ever got ARC I would keep it with me until I died and make it a family heirloom! They could definitely trade ARC with other bloggers

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I like the idea of heirlooms. I got some old books from when my mom was young and I loved those.

      Delete
  3. I've gotten a few ARC's. I would absolutely never sell them or buy them. If I read the ARC and didn't enjoy it, I simply hand it off to another reading buddy locally or host a quick giveaway to get it into the hands of a reader that wants it. :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Yeah, this discussion comes up every now and then, and there's a reason why it states on most ARC covers 'not for sale'. First of all, there aren't that many ARCs that get printed, so the cost for each of them is higher than for the finished book. Also, those ARCs are for review purposes, not for people to make money off the author's back, you know.
    In 2016, I went to BEA in Chicago, and even before the expo was over, there were much sought-after ARCs being sold on ebay. That some people who had actually been at the expo hadn't been able to get. And then - someone else just wanted that to make money.
    Great post, Myrth.
    Lexxie @ (un)Conventional Bookviews

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you!

      I'm seeing a pattern with this. There are really certain people who go out of their way to grab any ARC they can get (or maybe preferably mainstream books) for the sole purpose of selling them on ebay. It's a really sleazy way to make money. Not even those who pirate ebooks make money out of the free pdfs or epubs they share.

      Delete
  5. I do not believe in selling ARCs.

    With that being said, once a children's book has passed the sale date, I *do* donate my kids books arcs to the local after-school babysitting program library.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We don't have any kinds of programs like those in my country but I have a friend that creates those free standing mini libraries and accepts kids books because the literacy isn't as high as it used to be. More books for kids the better.

      Delete
  6. Chloe @ Book Dragons (I've still not managed to change my blogger account)

    I have two ARCs which I got through my library group called Reading Hack, I've read one which comes in February here in the UK but I think it's already out over in the US. Then the other ARC I have came out early Jan. I think selling ARC's is a total slap in the face to authors and publishers, the person got that copy for FREE and then makes money on it before it's even out? The only time I could maybe see it being ok is when the finalised copy of the book is out and its a few years on to then sell the ARC to a book collector etc.

    Also I hope you don't mind but I tagged you in this :)
    https://bookdragons247.wordpress.com/2018/01/22/the-mystery-blogger-award/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Getting ARCs is always a priviledge. At least now for us INTL bloggers we make connections and eventually we get sent those covered ARCs.

      Thanks for the tag. I'll check it out tomorrow.

      Delete
  7. I don't think it is alright to sell ARCs in any way, at whatever point down the road it comes and regardless of whether they are a backlist title or not. I think it is alright to trade them after a while - some book bloggers do that and they do so on the condition that if it has been traded the person who receives the ARC will then write and share a review too (and as they are trading arcs they will both be doing a review). That way from giving out one ARC the publisher gets 2 reviews - no harm done!

    My recent post: http://oliviascatastrophe.com/2018/01/lets-talk-about-love-book-review-giveaway/

    ReplyDelete
  8. The only time I see selling ARCs as acceptable is if all the profit goes towards charities. I've seen authors do this, where they donate all money. But other than that...I cherish all ARCs and eARCs I've ever received, and no matter if I end up liking the book or not, I'll never give them away.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Same here! Even the "worst" book would be kept as a collectible.

      Delete